Major differences between ASTM 1527-05 and 1527-13

Posted: January 1st, 2014 | Author: | Filed under: Uncategorized | Comments Off on Major differences between ASTM 1527-05 and 1527-13

The changes from the 2005 to 2013 ASTM standards do not significantly alter the Phase I ESA report or process, but there are a few key changes you should be aware of.

You may also want to ensure that your policy and contract documents reference the “most current” ASTM E1527 standard or update them to specifically reference the E1527-13 standard to ensure that you are receiving the most current standard and best quality report.

The most significant changes include:

File Reviews
The E1527-13 standard imposes a stronger imperative for conducting regulatory file reviews. The environmental professional reserves the right to forego such a review, but must explicitly explain in the report why a review is not warranted.

Vapor Migration
E1527-13 places greater emphasis on assessing impacts to the subject property from vapor migration. This is done through several changes in the standard: 1) clarifying that the definition of a release does include contamination in the soil vapor phase, not just in soil or groundwater; 2) adding a definition of “migration” that includes vapor (as well as soil and groundwater); and 3) clarifying that vapor migration/intrusion does not fall under the category of an Indoor Air Quality concern (which is out of the ASTM 1527 scope of work).

Several definitions have been clarified and simplified, and a new definition has been added of a “Controlled Recognized Environmental Condition” or “CREC.” You will now see CREC as an additional section being discussed in the executive findings and conclusions.

The simplest explanation of the difference between a Historical Recognized Environmental Condition or “HREC” and “CREC” is as follows:
HREC = A closed release that has been cleaned up to unrestricted use criteria (i.e. you could put a residence on the property)
CREC = A closed release that has been cleaned up but not to unrestricted use criteria, such as to “commercial/industrial standards” (i.e. you could not put a residence on the property)

Comments are closed.